View Full Version: Amazing Grace Reviews And Comments - MAY HOLD SPOILERS

ioanzone >>Amazing Grace >>Amazing Grace Reviews And Comments - MAY HOLD SPOILERS


<< Prev | Next >>

zoo.station- 07-23-2007

Bumping this up to let you know: The Herald Sun only gave Amazing Grace 2 stars this weekend. SLAVE TO GOOD INTENTIONS A recent article suggested the handsome young Welsh actor with the unpronounceable name of Ioan Gruffudd who played the dashing Captain Hornblower was having trouble getting work. The reason is plain. Likely employers had seen early rushes of Amazing Grace in which he plays 18th century anti-slavery campaigner William Wilberforce and were fearful Gruffudd would bore his audience to death. (ouch!) Perhaps the Brits banned the slave trade not because of any crisis of conscience but because MPs were forming support groups in the House of Commons as they wilted under Wilberforce's sermons about its evils. The film begins in the middle and is told in two directions, forward and back, a strategy that produces among dramatic dividends in exposing Wilberforce at his lowest ebb, drained of energy and confidence and suffering bouts of colitis. The film shows him experiencing a sudden religious revelation, and for a time he even considers leaving politics. The trouble is, he's such a dull chap. While hearing him relate his story, sexy minx Barbara Spooner (Romola Garai) makes the fatal mistake of cooing: 'Tell me about your last speech before Parliament." Amazingly, this dolt does just that. You may find yourself shouting at the screen: 'She doesn't care about that, you fool.' Neither does anyone else. What makes Wil such a splendid fellow is exactly what makes him a bore for Britain. Amazing Grace is a film that is at such great pains to show where its heart belongs - right up on its sleeve - and it has little time to waste on sex (wtf, since when does sex have anything to do with a man campaigning against the slave trade? ugh!), or slaves for that matter. Where we might expect to see ships burdened down by their suffering human cargoes and hear the crack of whips across bare backs, we get powdered wigs and a coughing fit brought on by Wilkberforce's laudanum addicted guts. Steven Knight's script - did he use a wuill pen dipped in molasses? - has the pace of a slaver adrift in the doldrums. And that title? It's based on the hymn composed by John Newton, the skipper of a slaver so appalled by the cruelty he witnessed that he spent the rest of his life atoning for his sins. Clarke Forbes. ...Well...That review pissed me, quite frankly. Talk about missing the point and the comment about sex...aargh!

StevieT- 07-23-2007

Well, I guess everyone's entiltled to their opinions ( :whistle ) but it all comes down to the attitude with which you see a film (reference discussion on FF2!) Mind you, I agree with the journalist, when they seem to be suggesting that the film would have benefitted from showing us a little more of Wilber and Barbera's relationship (or am I just starved of IG bedroom scenes, after the innocence of AG and FF2? Come on, Ioan! Show us your bum!) :wink:

zoo.station- 07-23-2007

Mind you, I agree with the journalist, when they seem to be suggesting that the film would have benefitted from showing us a little more of Wilber and Barbera's relationship (or am I just starved of IG bedroom scenes, after the innocence of AG and FF2? Come on, Ioan! Show us your bum!) :wink: Correct me if I am wrong, but isn't this movie primarily based on the slave trade or Wilberforce's movements to abolish it? Tell me, is sex all that important in a movie about politics and injustice. It seems that nowadays movies have to have some form of sexual object or activity and without one of those two things it's considered boring or a waste of time. What is going on that nothing can be kept private in movies anymore, we know when we see a movie that two people are in a relationship or married and I personally don't want to see their love in all it's entirety and forms and it's actually refreshing to see a movie when a female isn't being exploited and made into an object. Call me a prude, or tell me I have no idea but it drives me mental when critics whinge on about highly irrelevant subjects. That being said, sorry if I scared or upset you Stevie, none of that was directed at you it was just being said in general. :wink:

StevieT- 07-23-2007

:weeping

Frances- 07-23-2007

Correct me if I am wrong, but isn't this movie primarily based on the slave trade or Wilberforce's movements to abolish it? Tell me, is sex all that important in a movie about politics and injustice. No, it is not necessarily all that important that sex is introduced in any movie: it all depends on the story told and how it is told and I don't think it would be relevant in movie about slave trade and movements to abolish it. However, I guess that personal attitudes and expectations come into play here... Perhaps the journalist expected AG to focus on Wilberforce's private life as well as or more than on his political struggles. :dunno:

GNAT0629- 07-23-2007

I agree Kaitlyn. In some movies or stories, maybe it's necessary. But in this particular one it wasn't. And as for that guy wondering if anybody was shouting at the screen: She doesn't care about that you fool! Yeah I know I didn't. And I didn't find this movie boring or dragging at all. This guy obviously hasn't seen Spiderman 3. :wink:

Frances- 07-23-2007
A graceful force for freedom
July 24, 2007 http://www.theage.com.au/news/film/a-graceful-force-for-freedom/2007/07/23/1185043026157.html Michael Apted turned Amazing Grace into a story of activism allied with faith, writes Philippa Hawker. WHEN director Michael Apted went looking for a political subject for a movie, it took him far longer than he expected to find it. Apted — an Englishman now living in Los Angeles, whose CV includes the Seven Up documentary series, Bond film Die Another Day, Gorillas in the Mist and Coalminer's Daughter — says, on the phone from the US, that he had almost given up on the idea when a movie that he had already turned down became the project that he had been looking for. He had been approached to do a film about the 19th-century reformer William Wilberforce, who for years conducted a dogged parliamentary campaign against the slave trade. It came from production company Walden Media, known for its interest in family-friendly fare. The project had been around for some time: Australian director Bruce Beresford makes several references to his interest in the film in his new memoir, regretting that other commitments meant he could not take it on. The script that Apted read emphasised Wilberforce's strong religious faith, and was constructed as a traditional biopic. It wasn't the subject matter but the form that failed to capture Apted's imagination. But the idea of doing a different kind of film on the same topic made sense: something more dynamic, with more emphasis on the intensity of the political campaign. That's how Amazing Grace, a story of activism, came into being. He pitched the producers a different approach, and they agreed: he swiftly found scriptwriter Steven Knight (Dirty Pretty Things), who loved the period and the idea. Walden was on board the next day. The change of emphasis "made them nervous", Apted admits, "and it was an — I won't say a struggle — an ongoing debate through the making of the film. I reassured them that I didn't want to diminish or demean his spirituality, because it was a very resonant part of his character and his story. On the other hand, I wanted the film to find a bigger audience than a faith-based audience." He wanted young actors to play Wilberforce and his wife: his central character, was, after all, only 21 when he became an MP. Ioan Gruffudd (Hornblower, The Fantastic Four) was cast as Wilberforce, and Romola Garai (Mary Bryant, I Capture the Castle) as his wife, Barbara. And, he adds, he had no trouble finding a host of leading British actors to take supporting roles. "They liked the script and the idea of the film." Albert Finney said yes at once to the small but intense role of Wilberforce's mentor, John Newton, slave-ship captain turned Anglican priest, who wrote the song that gave the film its name. "I've been trying my whole working life to find something for him to be in," Apted says. Michael Gambon, who was working at the time on Robert De Niro's directorial debut, The Good Shepherd, which was running over schedule, "really had to put himself out for this, he fought to be in the film". He brings a sardonic wit to the part of Charles James Fox, the wily political operator whose support was crucial to Wilberforce's parliamentary tactics. Apted confesses that he hadn't thought of Rufus Sewell, often cast in swaggering or villainous roles, as Thomas Clarkson, one of the most important campaigners against the slave trade. "I had the more conventional view of Rufus, but he really went after it, and I thought he was great. No disrespect to Steven or me, but I thought he made something out of nothing." (His is a fleeting role.). And as Tarleton, one of the most prominent defenders of the slave trade, Apted cast Ciaran Hinds, an actor whose authority helps convey what lay behind his character's stand. Apted told Hinds, "from your point of view, everything you say is not true but terrifyingly true". There was a climate of fear, he says, "fear of the French Revolution, fear of what might happen when the people became involved in an issue", fear that the popular support that the abolitionists were seeking "could lead to a bloody revolution and a guillotine in Hyde Park". There are, he notes, many contemporary resonances to the film, many current echoes to be found in the 19th-century debate that took place. He wanted to present the context of it, to highlight "the fog, the moral confusion, the dilemmas" and also to show that activism needs to have political savvy. "Because, for all the moral outrage against slavery, nothing could be done until someone had the spirit and will and guts to turn the campaign into an act of parliament. Activism has to end up as a political manoeuvre, and that was the great gift Wilberforce brought to the table." But it's important, he says, "in the afterburn of the film, that the audience recognises that slavery hasn't ended with Wilberforce's campaign. It wasn't solved then and there, and it's not over now. Every generation has to deal, in its own way, with slavery." Amazing Grace opens Thursday. Cinema Nova previews the film today at 6.45 pm followed by a discussion on modern-day slavery with Julian Burnside QC, Mardy Bromberg SC and Kerryn Clarke. www.cinemanova.com.au

zoo.station- 07-27-2007

Hooray, finally a good review. Empire magazine loves it: http://www.empireonline.com.au/reviews/reviewcomplete.asp?FID=132925

Gaffer'sGirl- 08-01-2007

I came across a film review in the magazine Cineaste. They have the Ioan on the ship picture on the cover. Overall it is positive with only a few faults listed at the end. The review is two and a half pages so a little to much for me to type out and is mostly a re-hash of the story as opposed to comments on performances. There was one sentence that paid compliment to Ioan's voice. The reviewer describes Wilberforce and ends the paragraph with this: "His only character flaw is a bit of justifiable vanity about his singing voice, a strong clear tenor that belts out a certain hymn more than once." If I come across anything else of interest in re-reading, I will post it. GG

StevieT- 08-01-2007

Thanks GG! Interesting what different reporters pick up on, isn't it? Was he saying Ioan or Wilberforce was vain about his voice? I never got either from the film......

Gaffer'sGirl- 08-02-2007

I got the impression that he was saying Wilberforce had one vanity, but complimenting Ioan's voice. Just previous to that he was saying how Wilberforce was a man of uncommon virtue; made him almost sound like a saint, so I think that's why he called the pride in his voice a vanity. But, since none of us can hear Wilberforce sing, I'll take it that the strong, clear tenor was Ioan. By the by, I love your new avatar and Frances' also. Neither was a picture I've seen before. Not that the others were bad, but these - Nice! GG

zoo.station- 08-02-2007

I got the impression in Amazing Grace that William was actually quite confident and had a sense of vanity in regards to his singing voice, purely going by the comment he makes outside before going in and 'belting out' the hymn. Something about showing them how to sing or whatever? Seeing as it mentions tenor, and is supposedly referring to Ioan's voice, (I agree that it is a compliment) did Ioan make himself sound like a tenor or something? Ioan's a baritone isn't he? Thanks for the posting the info, GG.

StevieT- 08-02-2007

Cheers, GG! The pic is a screenshot from Happy Now (finally getting to grips with my software :roll: ) max is my favourite Ioan character at the moment....... :cloud9: I think you're right about the voice. Wonder what historical accounts exist about Wilberforce singing (interesting.....)

Gaffer'sGirl- 08-02-2007

The book I started reading said he had a fantastic voice that carried through large crowds and as in the movie when he was a young man, he was in demand as a singer. I don't recall his vocal range. Much of the movie was true in terms of the organizations he started or belonged to. He was the or one of the founders of the RSPCA and kind of that absent minded, too. Thought the picture was probably Max, but I've never seen the movie and not seen that particular picture. GG

Frances- 08-02-2007

By the by, I love your new avatar and Frances' also. Neither was a picture I've seen before. Mine is from a photo shoot on the occasion of AG premiere in the US.

Forumer™ is Voted #1 Free Forum Hosting provider
Build your own community today with the largest message board hosting company.